RuneScape Community Forums (since 2001)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5

Guess the best thing is to just judge them all based on their actions and hope they begin to slowly coexist each other and slowly eliminate the nh activity

I think in theory what you are saying makes sense, but the practicality of it doesn't. The clans today don't care about honor, respect or their place in the food chain. They will do what ever is necessary for their clan even if it is out of game tactics. Hoping that these same clans will participate in an honor based system is wishful thinking at best.

Clans that will use out of game tactics won't sign up to be apart of the system but will still hunt their rivals that are apart of it. If they aren't directly participating you can't do anything to stop them unfortunately.

This idea worked in the past because of the checks and balances of the clan world. No one wanted to be embargoed by clans on the RSC Top List so they stayed in line. When those same clans on the top list started taking things out of game it made matters worse.

(09-24-2018, 07:11 PM)Ryan Wrote: [ -> ]I think in theory what you are saying makes sense, but the practicality of it doesn't. The clans today don't care about honor, respect or their place in the food chain. They will do what ever is necessary for their clan even if it is out of game tactics. Hoping that these same clans will participate in an honor based system is wishful thinking at best.

Clans that will use out of game tactics won't sign up to be apart of the system but will still hunt their rivals that are apart of it. If they aren't directly participating you can't do anything to stop them unfortunately.

This idea worked in the past because of the checks and balances of the clan world. No one wanted to be embargoed by clans on the RSC Top List so they stayed in line. When those same clans on the top list started taking things out of game it made matters worse.

well thats why i believe to just force it on every clan out there. See how it goes, yes the idea of forcing something upon clans that dont want to participate in isn't right, but as i said to someone in sharkbrew. Main clanning is like your typical California blonde from LA. overly dramatic, and wants it her way all the time. Can't have that gotta step up and start laying the structures down at some point, right? Thats why i see forcing this down as a better alternative. Cause like everyone agrees, no one is going to get along fairly in the end. Hence the Cali blonde woman from LA comparison

(09-24-2018, 11:52 PM)Arck Wrote: [ -> ]
(09-24-2018, 07:11 PM)Ryan Wrote: [ -> ]I think in theory what you are saying makes sense, but the practicality of it doesn't. The clans today don't care about honor, respect or their place in the food chain. They will do what ever is necessary for their clan even if it is out of game tactics. Hoping that these same clans will participate in an honor based system is wishful thinking at best.

Clans that will use out of game tactics won't sign up to be apart of the system but will still hunt their rivals that are apart of it. If they aren't directly participating you can't do anything to stop them unfortunately.

This idea worked in the past because of the checks and balances of the clan world. No one wanted to be embargoed by clans on the RSC Top List so they stayed in line. When those same clans on the top list started taking things out of game it made matters worse.

well thats why i believe to just force it on every clan out there.

How do you plan on forcing a clan to follow your new method?

goodluck

(09-25-2018, 06:23 PM)Dox17 Wrote: [ -> ]
(09-24-2018, 11:52 PM)Arck Wrote: [ -> ]
(09-24-2018, 07:11 PM)Ryan Wrote: [ -> ]I think in theory what you are saying makes sense, but the practicality of it doesn't. The clans today don't care about honor, respect or their place in the food chain. They will do what ever is necessary for their clan even if it is out of game tactics. Hoping that these same clans will participate in an honor based system is wishful thinking at best.

Clans that will use out of game tactics won't sign up to be apart of the system but will still hunt their rivals that are apart of it. If they aren't directly participating you can't do anything to stop them unfortunately.

This idea worked in the past because of the checks and balances of the clan world. No one wanted to be embargoed by clans on the RSC Top List so they stayed in line. When those same clans on the top list started taking things out of game it made matters worse.

well thats why i believe to just force it on every clan out there.

How do you plan on forcing a clan to follow your new method?

Every clan posts a recap right? i just take all the details from that and publish that in a point system. Doing that already with the September results as a trial run. Ill post it up the end of the week

(09-26-2018, 03:47 AM)Arck Wrote: [ -> ]
(09-25-2018, 06:23 PM)Dox17 Wrote: [ -> ]
(09-24-2018, 11:52 PM)Arck Wrote: [ -> ]
(09-24-2018, 07:11 PM)Ryan Wrote: [ -> ]I think in theory what you are saying makes sense, but the practicality of it doesn't. The clans today don't care about honor, respect or their place in the food chain. They will do what ever is necessary for their clan even if it is out of game tactics. Hoping that these same clans will participate in an honor based system is wishful thinking at best.

Clans that will use out of game tactics won't sign up to be apart of the system but will still hunt their rivals that are apart of it. If they aren't directly participating you can't do anything to stop them unfortunately.

This idea worked in the past because of the checks and balances of the clan world. No one wanted to be embargoed by clans on the RSC Top List so they stayed in line. When those same clans on the top list started taking things out of game it made matters worse.

well thats why i believe to just force it on every clan out there.

How do you plan on forcing a clan to follow your new method?

Every clan posts a recap right? i just take all the details from that and publish that in a point system. Doing that already with the September results as a trial run. Ill post it up the end of the week

What about if two clans both post a win for the same fight?

(09-26-2018, 08:24 AM)Wee Man Wrote: [ -> ]
(09-26-2018, 03:47 AM)Arck Wrote: [ -> ]
(09-25-2018, 06:23 PM)Dox17 Wrote: [ -> ]
(09-24-2018, 11:52 PM)Arck Wrote: [ -> ]
(09-24-2018, 07:11 PM)Ryan Wrote: [ -> ]I think in theory what you are saying makes sense, but the practicality of it doesn't. The clans today don't care about honor, respect or their place in the food chain. They will do what ever is necessary for their clan even if it is out of game tactics. Hoping that these same clans will participate in an honor based system is wishful thinking at best.

Clans that will use out of game tactics won't sign up to be apart of the system but will still hunt their rivals that are apart of it. If they aren't directly participating you can't do anything to stop them unfortunately.

This idea worked in the past because of the checks and balances of the clan world. No one wanted to be embargoed by clans on the RSC Top List so they stayed in line. When those same clans on the top list started taking things out of game it made matters worse.

well thats why i believe to just force it on every clan out there.

How do you plan on forcing a clan to follow your new method?

Every clan posts a recap right? i just take all the details from that and publish that in a point system. Doing that already with the September results as a trial run. Ill post it up the end of the week

What about if two clans both post a win for the same fight?

It comes down to paying close attention to the screenshots. The other detail is video, that helps alot, but it really just comes down to paying attention to the screenies. I've seen some clans post a very big recap, only to see that the majority of their post is all spam pictures. The minimap itself is a dead give away, when clans try to claim a win yet their clump is beyond small. When two clans post a win it is a headache to deal with, but it is solvable.

(09-26-2018, 10:59 AM)Arck Wrote: [ -> ]It comes down to paying close attention to the screenshots. The other detail is video, that helps alot, but it really just comes down to paying attention to the screenies. I've seen some clans post a very big recap, only to see that the majority of their post is all spam pictures. The minimap itself is a dead give away, when clans try to claim a win yet their clump is beyond small. When two clans post a win it is a headache to deal with, but it is solvable.

Yeah, that's not going to work out well for you. Best of luck.

(09-26-2018, 03:59 PM)Wee Man Wrote: [ -> ]
(09-26-2018, 10:59 AM)Arck Wrote: [ -> ]It comes down to paying close attention to the screenshots. The other detail is video, that helps alot, but it really just comes down to paying attention to the screenies. I've seen some clans post a very big recap, only to see that the majority of their post is all spam pictures. The minimap itself is a dead give away, when clans try to claim a win yet their clump is beyond small. When two clans post a win it is a headache to deal with, but it is solvable.

Yeah, that's not going to work out well for you. Best of luck.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5